Damages in Pennsylvania Catastrophic Injury Cases: What You Can Recover and How Claims Are Valued

One of the biggest mistakes that can be made in a catastrophic injury case is trying to put a value on it too early.

In the first few weeks or months after a serious injury, there are plenty of numbers available. There are hospital bills. There may be surgery bills, rehabilitation expenses and lost paychecks. An insurance company may look at those numbers and make a settlement offer.

But those numbers only tell a small part of the story.

The harder questions are usually the ones nobody can answer yet.

Will another surgery be necessary? Will the injured person ever return to the same job? Will they need help at home? Will a spouse have to cut back on work to provide that help? Will the house need to be modified? What happens when a wheelchair or other medical equipment needs to be replaced years from now?

And perhaps most importantly: what is this person’s life actually going to look like five, ten or twenty years from now?

That is why valuing a catastrophic injury case is very different from adding up medical bills.

Need Help With Catastrophic Injuries in Pennsylvania?GET A FREE CONSULTATION.

CALL NOW
215-774-5162

What Damages Can Be Recovered After a Catastrophic Injury?

Every case is different, but damages in a serious Pennsylvania personal injury case can include much more than the expenses that have already been incurred.

Depending on the facts, an injured person may have a claim for past and future medical expenses, rehabilitation, lost wages, loss of future earning capacity, future personal care, assistive devices, transportation needs and modifications to a home or vehicle.

There are also losses that do not come with invoices.

Pennsylvania law allows injured people to seek compensation for non-economic harm such as pain and suffering, loss of life’s pleasures, embarrassment and humiliation, and disfigurement when supported by the facts of the case. A serious injury can also affect a marriage and, in appropriate circumstances, give rise to a spouse’s claim for loss of consortium.

These aren’t abstract legal categories when you’re living through them.

Suppose someone worked in construction before suffering a spinal cord injury. The loss isn’t simply the paychecks missed during six months of treatment. If that person can never return to physical work, the case may involve decades of lost earning capacity.

Or consider someone who suffers a traumatic brain injury and can still walk, drive and hold a conversation. On paper, that person may appear to have recovered well. But perhaps they can no longer concentrate for more than an hour, become overwhelmed in busy environments, forget appointments or cannot perform the job they spent 20 years building a career around.

Those details matter.

Medical Bills Are Only the Starting Point

People sometimes assume there must be a hard and fast formula for valuing an injury case.

There isn’t.

You cannot take the medical bills, multiply them by three or five, and arrive at the value of a catastrophic injury. Two people can undergo similar medical treatment and experience completely different long-term consequences.

What matters is what the injury did to this particular person.

Can you get dressed without help?

Can you climb the stairs in your own house?

Can you drive?

Can you cook dinner?

Can you pick up your child or grandchild?

Can you sleep through the night?

Can you return to the work you did before the accident?

Who is doing the things around the house that you used to do?

Those may sound like ordinary questions. In a catastrophic injury case, the answers can be enormously important.

We have seen how serious injuries ripple through entire families. A spouse becomes a caregiver. Parents who expected their adult child to live independently suddenly have to plan for decades of care. Someone who was the family’s primary wage earner becomes dependent on others.

Understanding damages means understanding those changes, not simply reading a diagnosis from a medical chart.

How Do You Put a Number on the Future?

This is one of the most important parts of a catastrophic injury case.

No lawyer or doctor can predict the future perfectly. But there is a major difference between guessing about future needs and developing evidence about them.

Treating physicians can provide opinions about prognosis, permanent limitations and anticipated medical treatment. Rehabilitation specialists can explain what a person can and cannot safely do. A life-care planner may identify future medical services, therapies, equipment, medications and assistance that are likely to be required and estimate how often those costs will occur.

Vocational experts may examine whether the person can return to their previous occupation or realistically perform other work. Economists and other financial experts can help calculate what lost earning capacity and future expenses mean over many years.

Family members often provide another important part of the picture because they see what happens outside the doctor’s office.

Who helps someone shower in the morning? Who drives them to therapy? Who makes the meals? Who handles the errands? Has a spouse changed work hours? Has the injured person stopped doing things they once did routinely?

That isn’t exaggerating a claim. It is documenting what actually changed.

A $10 Million Injury Does Not Automatically Mean There Is $10 Million to Recover

There is another reality families need to understand.

The value of the harm and the amount of money realistically available to compensate someone for that harm are two different questions.

A person may suffer devastating injuries and have damages worth millions of dollars. That does not necessarily mean the person who caused the injury has millions of dollars in insurance or assets.

This is one reason identifying every potentially responsible party can be so important in a catastrophic injury case.

A truck crash, for example, may involve questions about the driver, trucking company, vehicle owner, maintenance contractors, cargo companies or others depending on what happened. A defective-product case may involve manufacturers, distributors and other entities. Other cases can involve multiple insurance policies or different sources of coverage.

Determining what happened is only part of the investigation. Attorneys also need to determine who may legally be responsible and what insurance or other assets may be available.

That work should happen early.

Why Early Settlement Offers Can Be Dangerous

An early settlement offer can be tempting, particularly when someone has been unable to work and bills are arriving every week.

But an insurance company making an offer early in a case is answering a different question than the injured person needs answered.

The insurer is asking: What will it take to resolve this claim now?

The injured person needs to ask: What is this injury going to cost me and my family over the rest of my life?

Those numbers can be very different.

Imagine settling a case before doctors know whether another spinal surgery will be required. Or before anyone has determined that an injured worker will never return to the occupation that provided the family’s income. Or before it becomes clear that several hours of daily assistance will be necessary indefinitely.

Once a settlement agreement and release are signed, a personal injury claim generally cannot be reopened because the injury later turns out to be worse or more expensive than expected.

There are certainly cases where an early settlement makes sense. But in a catastrophic injury case, accepting one before the long-term medical and financial picture is understood can be a serious mistake.

Questions About Catastrophic Injuries?GET A FREE CONSULTATION.

CALL NOW
215-774-5162

Sometimes the Small Things Explain the Case Best

Medical records are essential, but they do not always capture what living with an injury is actually like.

A doctor’s note might say that a patient has reduced mobility. It probably will not say that the patient can no longer get into the upstairs bedroom and is sleeping downstairs.

A record may describe weakness in an arm. It may not explain that a parent can no longer lift their toddler.

A neurologist may document memory problems after a brain injury. The chart may not show that the person now needs three alarms to remember an appointment or that their spouse has taken over the household finances because bills were repeatedly forgotten.

Those facts can matter enormously when explaining damages to an insurance company, judge or jury.

Photographs, videos, employment records, testimony from coworkers and family members, and even a simple contemporaneous record of significant changes can help document a reality that medical terminology alone may not convey.

The point is not to turn someone’s suffering into a performance. It is to make sure the record accurately reflects what happened.

You May Need Time to Understand the Injury, But You Cannot Ignore the Deadline

Catastrophic injury cases create a difficult tension.

Sometimes it takes months or longer before doctors can give a reliable prognosis. From a damages standpoint, waiting for the medical picture to become clearer can be important.

The legal clock, however, keeps running.

Many Pennsylvania personal injury claims are subject to a two-year statute of limitations, and some claims can involve additional or earlier notice requirements, particularly where a government entity may be involved. The applicable deadline depends on the facts.

That means the legal investigation often needs to proceed while the medical treatment continues.

Evidence may need to be preserved. Witnesses may need to be identified. Vehicles, products, video, electronic records or other evidence can disappear. Potential defendants and insurance policies need to be investigated.

A family does not have to know exactly what the next 30 years will look like before beginning that work.

So What Is a Catastrophic Injury Case Worth?

There is no responsible way to answer that question from a diagnosis alone.

A spinal cord injury does not have a standard price. Neither does a traumatic brain injury, amputation, severe burn or any other life-changing injury.

The better question is much more detailed.

What did this person lose? What can they still do? What will they need? What income will they lose? What care will be required? How long will those needs continue? How has the injury changed the person’s daily life and family? Who is legally responsible? And what insurance or other resources are available to compensate them?

Answer those questions carefully and the value of the case begins to come into focus.

That process takes more work than adding up bills. In a catastrophic injury case, it should.

At Fulginiti Law, we represent people and families dealing with serious, permanent injuries. Part of our job is making sure a claim is not reduced to what can be measured in the first few weeks after an accident. We investigate what happened, identify the parties and insurance that may be responsible, work to understand the long-term medical and financial consequences, and build the evidence necessary to show what the injury has actually cost.

If you or a family member suffered a catastrophic injury in Pennsylvania, talk with us before signing a release or assuming an early insurance offer reflects the full value of the claim. The bills you can see today may be only the beginning.

Contact Fulginiti Law Today

Filing a pain and suffering claim in Pennsylvania can be overwhelming, but you don’t have to do it alone. If you or a loved one has suffered a catastrophic injury, contact Fulginiti Law today to evaluate your case and fight for the compensation you deserve.

Related Practice Resources

• Catastrophic Injury

Ready to Discuss Your Catastrophic Injuries Case?GET A FREE CONSULTATION.

CALL NOW
215-774-5162